Sign up for FREE Smoked Gouda • FREE Shipping at $99
A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler" containing rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The arched label features a bright red wood-grain background. At the top of the arch sits the "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese" logo, with a small yellow "Pride of NY" emblem to its right. Below this, the product name "HOT & SPICY CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized white font. The middle of the label displays four small square photos showing serving suggestions on crackers for each cheese variety included, listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante Cheddar: Paired with a red pepper slice. Ghost Pepper Cheddar: Paired with a light jelly or jam. Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar: Paired with a slice of roast beef. Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar: Paired with a fold of deli meat. The pre-sliced cheese slices are arranged neatly into four vertical rows matching the order on the label, showing off-white and pale green varieties peppered with spices. The bottom center indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g), flanked by small dietary icons on the left and a barcode on the right. A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler" containing rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The arched label features a bright red wood-grain background. At the top of the arch sits the "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese" logo, with a small yellow "Pride of NY" emblem to its right. Below this, the product name "HOT & SPICY CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized white font. The middle of the label displays four small square photos showing serving suggestions on crackers for each cheese variety included, listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante Cheddar: Paired with a red pepper slice. Ghost Pepper Cheddar: Paired with a light jelly or jam. Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar: Paired with a slice of roast beef. Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar: Paired with a fold of deli meat. The pre-sliced cheese slices are arranged neatly into four vertical rows matching the order on the label, showing off-white and pale green varieties peppered with spices. The bottom center indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g), flanked by small dietary icons on the left and a barcode on the right. Yancey's Fancy Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler Pack Unwrapped showing all 4 flavor cheeses listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante® Cheddar, Ghost Pepper Cheddar, Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar & Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar. Yancey's Fancy Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler Pack Unwrapped showing all 4 flavor cheeses listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante® Cheddar, Ghost Pepper Cheddar, Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar & Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Ghost Pepper" New York Cheddar cheese. The label is primarily deep red with a white arched border, featuring a graphic of a bright red ghost pepper in the center and faint, playful cartoon ghosts in the background. The text reads "Yancey's Fancy" in an arch at the top, followed by the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "GHOST PEPPER" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The bottom of the label indicates it is a "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" cheese with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g), accompanied by small flame and sun emojis to denote heat. Flakes of red pepper are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Ghost Pepper" New York Cheddar cheese. The label is primarily deep red with a white arched border, featuring a graphic of a bright red ghost pepper in the center and faint, playful cartoon ghosts in the background. The text reads "Yancey's Fancy" in an arch at the top, followed by the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "GHOST PEPPER" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The bottom of the label indicates it is a "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" cheese with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g), accompanied by small flame and sun emojis to denote heat. Flakes of red pepper are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Cayenne" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color scheme of deep brown, olive green, and maroon, illustrated with one whole green jalapeño pepper and two red cayenne peppers crossing over each other in the center. The background of the green section has faint line drawings of chili peppers. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Cayenne" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color scheme of deep brown, olive green, and maroon, illustrated with one whole green jalapeño pepper and two red cayenne peppers crossing over each other in the center. The background of the green section has faint line drawings of chili peppers. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Piquanté" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color gradient shifting from a dark forest green at the top, to a bright red in the middle, and finishing with a maroon section at the bottom. The central illustration displays a bright green jalapeño pepper lying horizontally behind three small, round, red piquanté peppers. Faint line drawings of chili peppers decorate the red background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "JALAPEÑO & PIQUANTÉ" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The maroon bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g) and includes three flame emojis to indicate the heat level. Distinct red and green pepper flecks are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Piquanté" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color gradient shifting from a dark forest green at the top, to a bright red in the middle, and finishing with a maroon section at the bottom. The central illustration displays a bright green jalapeño pepper lying horizontally behind three small, round, red piquanté peppers. Faint line drawings of chili peppers decorate the red background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "JALAPEÑO & PIQUANTÉ" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The maroon bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g) and includes three flame emojis to indicate the heat level. Distinct red and green pepper flecks are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Wasabi & Horseradish" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color palette that transitions from a vibrant grass green at the top to a light tan in the middle, and finishes with a teal blue section at the bottom. The central illustration features a small swirl of bright green grated wasabi paste next to a dollop of white, textured grated horseradish. The tan background section includes faint line drawings of sushi rolls, chopsticks, and horses. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "WASABI & HORSERADISH" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The teal bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a distinct, uniform light-green hue. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Wasabi & Horseradish" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color palette that transitions from a vibrant grass green at the top to a light tan in the middle, and finishes with a teal blue section at the bottom. The central illustration features a small swirl of bright green grated wasabi paste next to a dollop of white, textured grated horseradish. The tan background section includes faint line drawings of sushi rolls, chopsticks, and horses. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "WASABI & HORSERADISH" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The teal bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a distinct, uniform light-green hue.
A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler" containing rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The arched label features a bright red wood-grain background. At the top of the arch sits the "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese" logo, with a small yellow "Pride of NY" emblem to its right. Below this, the product name "HOT & SPICY CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized white font. The middle of the label displays four small square photos showing serving suggestions on crackers for each cheese variety included, listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante Cheddar: Paired with a red pepper slice. Ghost Pepper Cheddar: Paired with a light jelly or jam. Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar: Paired with a slice of roast beef. Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar: Paired with a fold of deli meat. The pre-sliced cheese slices are arranged neatly into four vertical rows matching the order on the label, showing off-white and pale green varieties peppered with spices. The bottom center indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g), flanked by small dietary icons on the left and a barcode on the right.
Yancey's Fancy Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler Pack Unwrapped showing all 4 flavor cheeses listed from left to right: Jalapeño & Piquante® Cheddar, Ghost Pepper Cheddar, Wasabi Horseradish Cheddar & Jalapeño & Cayenne Cheddar.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Ghost Pepper" New York Cheddar cheese. The label is primarily deep red with a white arched border, featuring a graphic of a bright red ghost pepper in the center and faint, playful cartoon ghosts in the background. The text reads "Yancey's Fancy" in an arch at the top, followed by the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "GHOST PEPPER" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The bottom of the label indicates it is a "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" cheese with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g), accompanied by small flame and sun emojis to denote heat. Flakes of red pepper are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Cayenne" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color scheme of deep brown, olive green, and maroon, illustrated with one whole green jalapeño pepper and two red cayenne peppers crossing over each other in the center. The background of the green section has faint line drawings of chili peppers.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Jalapeño & Piquanté" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color gradient shifting from a dark forest green at the top, to a bright red in the middle, and finishing with a maroon section at the bottom. The central illustration displays a bright green jalapeño pepper lying horizontally behind three small, round, red piquanté peppers. Faint line drawings of chili peppers decorate the red background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "JALAPEÑO & PIQUANTÉ" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The maroon bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g) and includes three flame emojis to indicate the heat level. Distinct red and green pepper flecks are visible throughout the creamy, off-white cheese block.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Wasabi & Horseradish" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color palette that transitions from a vibrant grass green at the top to a light tan in the middle, and finishes with a teal blue section at the bottom. The central illustration features a small swirl of bright green grated wasabi paste next to a dollop of white, textured grated horseradish. The tan background section includes faint line drawings of sushi rolls, chopsticks, and horses. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "WASABI & HORSERADISH" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The teal bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a distinct, uniform light-green hue.

Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler

$14.99
The Yancey’s Fancy Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler delivers an artisan tasting experience for heat lovers. Available in 12 oz and 18 oz packs, it comes pre-sliced into small charcuterie slices for easy entertaining.
Gluten Free · rBST Free · Lactose Free
Size *
Add to Wishlist

Yancey’s Fancy Hot & Spicy Cheese Sampler delivers a bold, flavor-forward tasting experience for heat lovers who enjoy a mix of spice, complexity, and artisan-style cheddar. Available in 12 oz and 18 oz packs, this collection features the exact same delicious flavors; the 18 oz option just gives you more of each to love! Every pack comes pre-sliced and charcuterie-ready, making it easier than ever to build the perfect party platter or fiery snack. 

This curated collection features four distinct varieties, each crafted to highlight a different level of heat and flavor intensity:

  • Jalapeño & Piquante: A vibrant, zesty option featuring a subtle sweet-heat balance and a colorful pop of pepper.
  • Wasabi Horseradish: A sharp, sinus-clearing bite with a unique, pungent kick that beautifully cuts through the rich cheddar.
  • Jalapeño & Cayenne: A double-dose of classic pepper heat, offering a bright, sharp, and savory spice profile.
  • Ghost Pepper: For the truly adventurous; an intense, fiery, and lingering heat that pushes the boundaries of bold flavor.

The creamy cheddar base in every variety helps balance the spice, ensuring each bite remains smooth, rich, and deeply satisfying. Perfect for effortless entertaining, game days, or adventurous snacking, this sampler is designed for those who love exploring bold flavor combinations.

The Yancey’s Fancy Hot & Spicy Sampler is the ultimate shortcut to elevating your next cheese board with artisan-quality craftsmanship and unforgettable heat.

World-Class Cheese, No Travel Required

Flat-Rate Shipping

Temperature-Controlled

Fast & Fresh

Related Products