star arrow-up arrow-left arrow-right close arrow-down search check-mark plus minus avatar calendar delete edit phone spinner8
Free Gift at $79 | Free Shipping at $99
account Sign In
Yancey's Fancy
Compare up to 4 items:
Clear Selection
Compare
wishlist
0
Yancey's Fancy
  • Cheese Shop
    • Shop By Type
      • Cheddar
      • Gouda
      • Cheese Dips
      • Cheese Curds
      • Cheese Shareables
    • Shop by Cut
      • Slices
      • Wedges
      • Wheels
    • Shop by Flavor
      • Savory Classics
      • Spicy & Bold
      • Herb & Garden
      • Sweet & Savory
      • Zesty Bites
      • Grand Reserve
    • Shop All
    • Charcuterie
  • Charcuterie
    • Shop Charcuterie
      • Shop All
      • Charcuterie Packs
      • Summer Sausage & Cheese Packs
      • Recipe Kits
      • Cheese Bundles
      • Meats
    • Cheese Bundles
    • Charcuterie Packs
    • Meats
  • Entertaining: How to Fancy it?
    • Entertaining
    • Mac and Cheese
    • Cantina Classics
    • Cheese Dips
    • Grilling & Melting
    • Yancey's Recipes
    • Build a Charcuterie Board

Yancey's Fancy | Artisan Cheese & Gourmet Products

Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavors.
Sample alt text
Introducing Parmigiora:

EXTRA MOISTURE, ZERO CRUMBLES

A whole new way to cheese. Discover our new artisan hard cheese crafted to melt smoothly, slice effortlessly, and elevate your everyday snacking.
Try Parmigiora First
Sample alt text
The Ultimate High-Protein Snack: Fresh Cheese Curds Squeaky, salty, and loaded with protein! Stock up on artisanal cheese curds for your next road trip, hike, or afternoon snack attack.
Shop Cheese Curds
Sample alt text
Get Cooking with Yancey’s Fancy Cheeses Turn up the flavor in your kitchen! Explore easy, mouthwatering recipes made with your favorite bold and artisanal Yancey’s cheeses.
Explore Our Recipes
THIS WEEK'S DEAL: Get a FREE wedge of Maple Bacon Cheddar for orders $79+!

Shop Our Flavors

  • Spicy & Bold
  • Savory Classics
  • Herb & Garden
  • Sweet & Savory
  • Zesty Bites
  • Grand Reserve
The Ube Gouda

The Ube Gouda Restock Has Landed

You asked, we delivered! Our viral Ube Gouda cheese is officially back in stock with a fresh new batch ready to slice.

Snag Your Wedge
The Ube Gouda

Meet Your New Favorite Charcuterie Bundles

Big flavor, zero hassle. Explore our new gourmet meat & cheese sets featuring specialty cured meats and fresh cheeses.

Snag Your Bundle

SHOP YANCEY'S FANCY CUSTOMER FAVORITES

Smoked Gouda Wedge Smoked Gouda Wedge
Your Grill’s New Best Friend. Unlock a FREE Smoked Gouda cheese wedge with your first email sign-up. Smooth, smoky, and the perfect melt for your BBQ. (New subscribers only)
Reach $99 and we’ll cover the shipping, too!
Unlock Free Cheese Shop ALL FLAVOR

EXPLORE OUR DELICIOUS RECIPE KITS

A cheese entertaining kit showing a close-up of a "cheese pull" from a melted cheese dip.
THE ENTERTAINING HUB

Artisan Cheese Kits: Master the Melt.

Ditch the basic appetizer spread. Discover our curated cheese Entertaining Kits designed to give you the perfect cheese pull for gourmet burgers, gooey fondues, and epic mac and cheese.

 Shop Entertaining Kits

Frequently Asked Questions

You can buy our full lineup of artisan cheese blocks, exclusive 5-cheese entertaining kits, and gift crates directly right here on our official website.

Yancey's Fancy is proudly handcrafted in Corfu, New York. We combine our deep Bavarian roots with New York's rich dairy history to produce our bold, artisan cheeses.

For the best tasting experience, we recommend consuming our artisan cheeses within 3 to 4 weeks after opening the package. Always keep the cheese tightly wrapped in plastic or parchment paper and stored in the refrigerator to maintain its rich, bold flavor.

Featured Products

Yancey's Fancy Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce Cheese 1.25 pound wedge.
Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce Cheddar
Spicy & Bold
Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce Cheddar
From$11.99
Fancy's Favorite
Yancey's Fancy Chesapeake Bay Cheddar large club-cut wedge.
Chesapeake Bay Cheddar
Chesapeake Bay Cheddar
$12.45
Limited Release
A bag of Yancey's Fancy Chive Cheddar Artisan Cheese Curds with cheese curds tumbling into a bowl. The packaging highlights 110 calories, 0g carbs, and 7g protein per serving against a vibrant green background.
Chive Cheddar Cheese Curds
Chive Cheddar Cheese Curds
From$8.99
A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Artisan Cheese Sampler" featuring rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The label has a dark brown wood-grain background with an arched top. At the peak of the arch, the brand logo reads "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese." Below this, the product name "ARTISAN CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized, rustic white font.
The label is divided into four distinct colored blocks that detail each variety included, from left to right:
Green block: "Horseradish" (Pasteurized Process) – The original horseradish cheddar since 1952.
Orange block: "Buffalo Wing" (Pasteurized Process) – The original hot sauce cheddar.
Light Yellow block: "Smoked Gouda" (Pasteurized Process) – Naturally cold blended & smoked.
Yellow block: "New York Sharp" (Pasteurized Process) – Hand-crafted aged cheddar cheese.

The pre-sliced cheeses are arranged neatly in rows corresponding to their position on the label, transitioning from an off-white horseradish cheddar on the far left, to a speckled orange buffalo wing cheddar, a pale yellow smoked gouda, and a bright orange sharp cheddar on the far right. The bottom right of the label indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g).
Artisan Cheese Sampler
Artisan Cheese Sampler
From$14.99
Yancey's Fancy Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla Recipe Cheese bundle.
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla - Cheese Kit
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla - Cheese Kit
$42.45
Yancey's Fancy Ghost Pepper Inferno Nacho Recipe Cheese Bundle.
Cantina Classic Queso Nacho - Cheese Kit
Cantina Classic Queso Nacho - Cheese Kit
$32.50
Yancey's Fancy VIP Truffle Steakhouse Gourmet Mac & Cheese cheese bundles.
VIP Truffle Steakhouse Gourmet Mac 'n' Cheese - Cheese Kit
VIP Truffle Steakhouse Gourmet Mac 'n' Cheese - Cheese Kit
$49.95
Yancey’s Fancy Bracket Buster Pizza Fondue & Graze Kit.
Bracket Buster Pizza Fondue - Cheese Kit
Bracket Buster Pizza Fondue - Cheese Kit
$42.45

Subscribe to our newsletter!

About Us

Our Story

How Cheese is Made

Careers

Shipping Details

Seen in the Press

Customer Care

Get In Touch

FAQs

Cheese Near Me

1-585-599-0224
Monday - Friday 8AM - 5PM EST

© Yancey's Fancy
Terms & ConditionsPrivacyShipping & ReturnsAccessibilityMachine Readable Files

Stay Connected

  • facebook Facebook
  • instagram Instagram
  • linkedin LinkedIn
  • TikTok
account Account wishlist Wishlist Shopping bag

Your shopping bag

Your bag is empty!

Account

Log in

Forgot password?

New Customer

Create an account with us and you'll be able to:

  • Check out faster
  • Save multiple shipping addresses
  • Access your order history
  • Track new orders
  • Save items to your wish list
Create Account

Forgot Password

Forgot Password

Fill in your email below to request a new password. An email will be sent to the address below containing a link to verify your email address.