Free Shipping at $99

Compare up to 4 items:

Clear Selection

Compare

Cheese Shop
- Shop By Type
- Shop by Cut
  - Slices
  - Wedges
  - Wheels
- Shop by Flavor
- Shop All
- Charcuterie
Charcuterie
Entertaining: How to Fancy it?

Shop Our Flavors

Spicy & Bold
Savory Classics
Herb & Garden
Sweet & Savory
Zesty Bites
Grand Reserve

Shop All

Sort By:

Add Filters

Price

Sort By:

Yancey's Fancy Chesapeake Bay Cheddar large club-cut wedge.

Chesapeake Bay Cheddar

$12.45

Limited Release

Yancey's Fancy snackable parmigiora 3 pound wheel with label.

Parmigiora

$49.99

New Product

A bag of Yancey's Fancy Hot Pepper Cheddar Artisan Cheese Curds with cheese curds tumbling into a bowl. The packaging highlights 110 calories, 0g carbs, and 7g protein per serving against a vibrant red background.

Hot Pepper Cheddar Cheese Curds

From$8.99

Yancey’s Fancy Piquante Cheddar Cheese.

Spicy & Bold

Piquante (Aka Peppadew) Cheddar

From$12.45

Subscribe to our newsletter!

yourname@email.com

About Us

How Cheese is Made

Customer Care

1-585-599-0224
Monday - Friday 8AM - 5PM EST

© Yancey's Fancy

Terms & Conditions Privacy Shipping & Returns Accessibility Machine Readable Files

Stay Connected

Facebook
Instagram
LinkedIn
TikTok

Account Wishlist Shopping bag

Your shopping bag

Your bag is empty!

Account

Log in

Email Address *

Password *

Forgot password?

New Customer

Create an account with us and you'll be able to:

Check out faster
Save multiple shipping addresses
Access your order history
Track new orders
Save items to your wish list

Forgot Password

Forgot Password

Fill in your email below to request a new password. An email will be sent to the address below containing a link to verify your email address.

Email Address *