FREE Smoked Gouda at $50 • FREE Shipping at $75
A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Artisan Cheese Sampler" featuring rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The label has a dark brown wood-grain background with an arched top. At the peak of the arch, the brand logo reads "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese." Below this, the product name "ARTISAN CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized, rustic white font. The label is divided into four distinct colored blocks that detail each variety included, from left to right: Green block: "Horseradish" (Pasteurized Process) – The original horseradish cheddar since 1952. Orange block: "Buffalo Wing" (Pasteurized Process) – The original hot sauce cheddar. Light Yellow block: "Smoked Gouda" (Pasteurized Process) – Naturally cold blended & smoked. Yellow block: "New York Sharp" (Pasteurized Process) – Hand-crafted aged cheddar cheese. The pre-sliced cheeses are arranged neatly in rows corresponding to their position on the label, transitioning from an off-white horseradish cheddar on the far left, to a speckled orange buffalo wing cheddar, a pale yellow smoked gouda, and a bright orange sharp cheddar on the far right. The bottom right of the label indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g). Yancey's Fancy Artisan Cheese Sampler pack unwrapped featuring Horseradish, Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce, Smoked Gouda, New York Sharp Cheddar. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Horseradish" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color palette that transitions from a muted teal-green at the top to a light tan in the middle, and finishes with a solid teal section at the bottom. The central illustration depicts a whole horseradish root, partially sliced into rounds, next to a small pile of freshly grated white horseradish. Faint line drawings of horses decorate the tan background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "HORSERADISH" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The teal bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a clean, uniform, creamy off-white color. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color scheme that transitions from a deep red at the top, down to a bright orange-red in the middle, and finishes with a dark brown section at the bottom. The central illustration captures a dramatic splash of bright red hot sauce. Faint line drawings of buffalo silhouettes decorate the orange-red background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "BUFFALO WING HOT SAUCE" is written in large, bold white capital letters across two lines. The dark brown bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g) and includes three small flame emojis to signify a high heat level. The cheese block itself is a vibrant orange color with small reddish pepper flecks visible throughout. A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Smoked Gouda" New York Gouda cheese. The arched label features a color scheme that transitions from a dark smoky bronze at the top, down to a light cream in the middle, and finishes with a bright reddish-orange section at the bottom. The background of the cream section is decorated with faint, elegant swirls meant to resemble rising smoke. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "SMOKED GOUDA" is written in large, bold white capital letters across two lines. The reddish-orange bottom section reads "New York Gouda Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a smooth, uniform pale yellow-orange color.
A plastic, vacuum-sealed sampler tray of Yancey's Fancy "Artisan Cheese Sampler" featuring rows of pre-sliced cheese varieties. The label has a dark brown wood-grain background with an arched top. At the peak of the arch, the brand logo reads "Yancey's Fancy New York's Artisan Cheese." Below this, the product name "ARTISAN CHEESE SAMPLER" is written in a stylized, rustic white font. The label is divided into four distinct colored blocks that detail each variety included, from left to right: Green block: "Horseradish" (Pasteurized Process) – The original horseradish cheddar since 1952. Orange block: "Buffalo Wing" (Pasteurized Process) – The original hot sauce cheddar. Light Yellow block: "Smoked Gouda" (Pasteurized Process) – Naturally cold blended & smoked. Yellow block: "New York Sharp" (Pasteurized Process) – Hand-crafted aged cheddar cheese. The pre-sliced cheeses are arranged neatly in rows corresponding to their position on the label, transitioning from an off-white horseradish cheddar on the far left, to a speckled orange buffalo wing cheddar, a pale yellow smoked gouda, and a bright orange sharp cheddar on the far right. The bottom right of the label indicates a net weight of 12 oz (340g).
Yancey's Fancy Artisan Cheese Sampler pack unwrapped featuring Horseradish, Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce, Smoked Gouda, New York Sharp Cheddar.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Horseradish" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color palette that transitions from a muted teal-green at the top to a light tan in the middle, and finishes with a solid teal section at the bottom. The central illustration depicts a whole horseradish root, partially sliced into rounds, next to a small pile of freshly grated white horseradish. Faint line drawings of horses decorate the tan background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "HORSERADISH" is written in large, bold white capital letters. The teal bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a clean, uniform, creamy off-white color.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce" New York Cheddar cheese. The arched label features a color scheme that transitions from a deep red at the top, down to a bright orange-red in the middle, and finishes with a dark brown section at the bottom. The central illustration captures a dramatic splash of bright red hot sauce. Faint line drawings of buffalo silhouettes decorate the orange-red background section. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "BUFFALO WING HOT SAUCE" is written in large, bold white capital letters across two lines. The dark brown bottom section reads "New York Cheddar Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g) and includes three small flame emojis to signify a high heat level. The cheese block itself is a vibrant orange color with small reddish pepper flecks visible throughout.
A vacuum-sealed block of Yancey's Fancy "Smoked Gouda" New York Gouda cheese. The arched label features a color scheme that transitions from a dark smoky bronze at the top, down to a light cream in the middle, and finishes with a bright reddish-orange section at the bottom. The background of the cream section is decorated with faint, elegant swirls meant to resemble rising smoke. The text at the top reads "Yancey's Fancy" arched above the tagline "Simple Ingredients. Bold Flavor." The product name "SMOKED GOUDA" is written in large, bold white capital letters across two lines. The reddish-orange bottom section reads "New York Gouda Pasteurized Process" with a net weight of 7.6 oz (215 g). The block of cheese itself has a smooth, uniform pale yellow-orange color.

Artisan Cheese Sampler

$12.99
Looking for the best gouda and cheddar variety pack? The Yancey’s Fancy Artisan Cheese Sampler delivers a premium tasting experience. Available in 12 oz and 18 oz packs, it comes pre-sliced into small
Gluten Free · rBST Free · Lactose Free
Size *
Add to Wishlist

Yancey’s Fancy Artisan Cheese Sampler brings together a thoughtfully curated selection of New York–style artisan cheeses, offering a diverse tasting experience that highlights bold flavors, quality ingredients, and expert craftsmanship. Available in 12 oz and 18 oz packs, this collection features the exact same delicious flavors; the 18 oz option just gives you more of each to love! Every pack comes pre-sliced and charcuterie-ready, making it easier than ever to build the perfect party platter. This premium assortment is proudly gluten-free, lactose-free, and rBST-free.

This curated collection features four distinctive cheese varieties, carefully blended to deliver a range of classic and bold taste profiles:

  • Horseradish Cheddar: A bold fusion of aged cheddar and freshly ground horseradish, delivering a sharp, zesty kick balanced by the smooth richness of cheddar.
  • Buffalo Wing Hot Sauce Cheddar: A fiery, flavor-packed blend of aged cheddar, habanero, cayenne, and jalapeño peppers, finished with original Buffalo Wing hot sauce for a layered, tangy heat.
  • Smoked Gouda: A smooth, European-style cheese naturally smoked for added depth, offering a warm, savory richness with a subtle smoky finish.
  • Sharp Cheddar: A classic, full-bodied cheddar with a bold, tangy bite and buttery undertones, delivering a robust and traditional cheddar experience.

The high-quality cheddar and Gouda bases in every variety ensure each bite remains smooth, rich, and deeply satisfying. Perfect for effortless entertaining, gifting, or personal indulgence, this sampler is designed for those who appreciate variety, richness, and authentic flavor.

The Yancey’s Fancy Artisan Cheese Sampler is the ultimate shortcut to elevating your next cheese board with artisan-quality craftsmanship and a well-rounded exploration of bold profiles.

World-Class Cheese, No Travel Required

Flat-Rate Shipping

Temperature-Controlled

Fast & Fresh

Related Products